new version V2017

thrombosis prevention

     

TrialStudied treatmentControl treatmentpatientsROBResultNCT

antithrombotics

acenocoumarol
van Geloven, 1977Acenocoumarolunfractionated heparin -
Hamulyak, 1994AcenocoumarolNadroparinNegative
Samama, 2001AcenocoumarolReviparinNegative
apixaban
APROPOS 2.5mg, 2007apixabanenoxaparin (US regimen)knee surgery Exploratory NegativeNCT00097357
ADVANCE-1, 2008apixabanenoxaparin (US regimen)knee surgery Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00371683
ADVANCE 3, 2010apixabanenoxaparinhip surgery Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00423319
ADVANCE 2, 2010apixabanenoxaparin (europe regimen)knee surgery Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00452530
ADOPT, 2011apixabanenoxaparinmedical patients Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00457002
CV185-027 ongoing apixabanplacebo - NCT00320255
ardeparin
Godwin, 1993ardeparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Levine, 1996ardeparinplaceboknee surgerySuggesting
Heit, 2000out of hospital Ardeparinstandard prophylaxisNegative
aspirin
MRC, 1972aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias Negative
Loew DVT, 1974aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias -
Clagett, 1975aspirincontrol Risk of bias -
Stockholm-I, 1975Aspirinplacebo Exploratory Negative
Pasteyer, 1977Aspirinno treatment Exploratory Negative
Vinazzer II, 1977aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias -
Harris-I, 1977Aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias Suggesting
Erfurt-A, 1979aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias -
Zekert V, 1980aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias -
Vinazzer I, 1980aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias -
McKenna-I, 1980Aspirinplacebo Exploratory Suggesting
Zekert VI, 1982aspirincontrol Risk of bias -
Sautter, 1983Aspirinplacebo Exploratory Suggesting
McBride, 1983Aspirinplacebo Exploratory Negative
Rocha, 1986Aspirinno treatment Exploratory Suggesting
PEP hip-fracture, 2000aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias Suggesting
PEP elective arthroplasty, 2000aspirinplacebo Low risk of bias -
betrixaban
APEX, 2016betrixabanenoxaparinmedical patients Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT01583218
candesartan
Eriksson, 1996desirudinUFH -
Ericksson, 1997desirudinenoxaparin -
REVASC, 1997desirudinUFH -
Certoparin
Schmitz-Huebner, 1984certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Sasahara, 1986certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgerySuggesting
Voigt, 1986certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Haas , 1987certoparine + DHEUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Lassen, 1988certoparine + DHEUnfractionated heparinhip surgerySuggesting
Welzel, 1988certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgerySuggesting
Lassen, 1989certoparine + DHEUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Kakkar, 1989certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Adolf, 1989certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Heilmann, 1989certoparinunfractionated heparingynaecological surgeryNegative
Baumgartner, 1989certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Hoffmann and Largiade, 1990certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Koppenhagen, 1990certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Schielke, 1991certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Koppenhagen, 1992certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Hoffmann and Largiader, 1992certoparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Kock, 1995certoparincontrol Risk of bias Negative
Heilmann, 1997certoparinunfractionated heparingynaecological surgery -
Haas, 1999certoparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgery -
CERTIFY, 2010certoparinUFHmedical patients -
dabigatran
RE-NOVATE 2dabigatran 220mgenoxaparinhip surgery Low risk of bias NegativeNCT00657150
RE-NOVATE (220mg), 2007dabigatran 220mgenoxaparinhip surgery Low risk of bias NegativeNCT00168818
RE-NOVATE (150mg), 2007dabigatran 150mgenoxaparinhip surgery Low risk of bias Negative NCT00168818
RE-MODEL (220mg), 2007dabigatran 220mgenoxaparin (europe regimen)knee surgery Low risk of bias Negative
RE-MODEL (150mg), 2007dabigatran 150mgenoxaparin (europe regimen)knee surgery Low risk of bias Negative
RE-MOBILIZE (220mg), 2008dabigatran 220mgenoxaparin (US regimen)knee surgery Low risk of bias Negative
RE-MOBILIZE (150mg), 2008dabigatran 150mgenoxaparin (US regimen)knee surgery Low risk of bias Negative
dalteparin
Haas , 1985dalteparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Binsack , 1986dalteparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Bergqvist, 1986dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Onarheim, 1986dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Koller, 1986dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Koller, 1986dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Barre , 1987dalteparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Eriksson , 1988dalteparinDextranhip surgerySuggesting
Matzsch , 1988dalteparinDextranhip surgeryNegative
Fricker, 1988dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Bergqvist, 1988dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Caen, 1988dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgeryNegative
Borstad, 1988dalteparinunfractionated heparingynaecological surgeryNegative
Briel, 1988dalteparinunfractionated heparinnon orthopedic surgeryNegative
Ockelford , 1989dalteparinplaceboSuggesting
Jorgensen, 1989dalteparinplacebohip surgerySuggesting
Dechavanne , 1989dalteparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Eriksson , 1989dalteparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgerySuggesting
Monreal , 1989dalteparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Scala, 1990dalteparinUFH Risk of bias Negative
Creperio, 1990dalteparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgeryNegative
Hartl, 1990dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgerySuggesting
Matzsch , 1991dalteparinDextranhip surgerySuggesting
Torholm, 1991dalteparinplacebohip surgerySuggesting
Borstad, 1992dalteparinunfractionated heparingynaecological surgery -
Kakkar, 1993dalteparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Dahl, 1997out of hospital Dalteparinstandard prophylaxisSuggesting
Lassen, 1998out of hospital Dalteparinstandard prophylaxisNegative
Hull, 2000out of hospital Dalteparinstandard prophylaxisSuggesting
Leizorovicz, 2004dalteparinplacebomedical patientsSuggesting
Lapidus, 2007dalteparinplacebo Low risk of bias Negative
Lapidus, 2007dalteparinplacebo Low risk of bias Negative
D-KAf (Selby), 2007dalteparinplaceboNegativeNCT00187408
PROTECT, 2011dalteparinUFHmedical patients Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00182143
deltaparin
Michot, 2002deltaparincontrol Risk of bias Suggesting
dipyridamol
Parodi I, 1973dipyridamol + aspirincontrol Exploratory Suggesting
Parodi II, 1973dipyridamol + aspirincontrol Risk of bias -
Australian I, 1975dipyridamol + aspirincontrol Risk of bias -
Lyon-I, 1975aspirin + dipyridamolno treatment Exploratory Suggesting
Australian II, 1976dipyridamol + aspirincontrol Risk of bias -
Encke IA, 1976dipyridamol + aspirinplacebo Exploratory -
Encke IB, 1976dipyridamol + aspirinplacebo Exploratory -
Hamburg, 1976aspirin + dipyridamolplacebo Exploratory Negative
Zekert-III, 1977dipyridamol + aspirincontrol Risk of bias -
Weiss, 1977dipyridamol + aspirincontrol Exploratory -
Toulouse I, 1979dipyridamol + aspirincontrol Risk of bias -
Frankfurt, 1981aspirin + dipyridamolplacebo Exploratory Negative
Harjola DVT, 1982dipyridamol + aspirincontrol Risk of bias -
Chicago, 1982aspirin + dipyridamolcontrol Exploratory Negative
edoxaban
STARS J-Vedoxabanenoxaparin (short duration)hip surgery Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT01181167
DU176b-B-J302 ongoing edoxabanenoxaparinknee surgery - NCT01181102
DU176b-B-J303 ongoing edoxabanenoxaparinhip surgery - NCT01181141
DU176b-B-J304 ongoing edoxabanenoxaparinhip surgery - NCT01181167
DU176b-04 ongoing edoxabanplaceboknee surgery - NCT01203072
enoxaparin
Ho [43]enoxaparinno treatmentNegative
Turpie, 1986enoxaparinplacebohip surgerySuggesting
LeGagneux , 1987enoxaparinplaceboNegative
Melon, 1987enoxaparinplaceboNegative
Planes , 1988enoxaparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgerySuggesting
Samama 1, 1988enoxaparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgeryNegative
Samama 2, 1988enoxaparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgeryNegative
Samama 3, 1988enoxaparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgeryNegative
DES Group , 1991enoxaparinDextranhip surgerySuggesting
Leclerc, 1991enoxaparinplaceboknee surgerySuggesting
Levine , 1991enoxaparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Kaaja, 1992enoxaparinunfractionated heparingynaecological surgery -
Gazzaniga (ISG), 1993enoxaparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgery -
Warwick, 1995enoxaparinno treatmenthip surgeryNegative
Nurmohamed, 1995enoxaparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgery -
McLeod (Canadian), 1995enoxaparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Kalodiki, 1996enoxaparinplacebohip surgery -
Bergqvist, 1996out of hospital Enoxaparinstandard prophylaxisSuggesting
Planes, 1996out of hospital Enoxaparinstandard prophylaxisNegative
Bergmann and Neuhart, 1996enoxaparinUFHmedical patientsNegative
Lechler, 1996enoxaparinUFHmedical patientsNegative
Gonzalez, 1996enoxaparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Samama, 1997enoxaparinplacebohip surgerySuggesting
ENOXACAN, 1997enoxaparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Agnelli, 1998enoxaparinplaceboSuggesting
MEDENOX, 1999Enoxaparinplacebomedical patients Low risk of bias Suggesting
Comp, 2001out of hospital Enoxaparinstandard prophylaxisSuggesting
Canata, 2003enoxaparincontrol Exploratory Negative
Kleber, 2003enoxaparinUFHmedical patientsNegative
Lederle, 2006Enoxaparinplacebomedical patientsNegative
LIFENOX, 2011enoxaparinplacebomedical patients Low risk of bias NegativeNCT00622648
fondaparinux
BRiEFfondaparinuxenoxaparinmedical patients - NCT00521885
L8541fondaparinuxenoxaparinorthopaedic surgery Low risk of bias Negative
L8635fondaparinuxenoxaparinknee surgery Exploratory Negative
DRI4757fondaparinuxplaceboknee surgery Exploratory -
PENTAMAKS (Bauer), 2001fondaparinuxenoxaparinknee surgery Low risk of bias Suggesting
PENTHIFRA (Eriksson), 2001fondaparinuxenoxaparinhip surgery Low risk of bias Suggesting
Turpie, 2001fondaparinuxenoxaparinhip surgery Exploratory -
PENTATHLON (Turpie), 2002fondaparinuxenoxaparinhip surgery Low risk of bias Suggesting
EPHESUS (Lassen), 2002fondaparinuxenoxaparinhip surgerySuggesting
PEGASUS, 2005fondaparinuxenoxaparinabdominal surgery Low risk of bias Negative
ARTEMIS (Cohen), 2006fondaparinuxplacebomedical patientsNegative
APOLLO (Turpie), 2007fondaparinuxplacebo (on top intermittent pneumatic comp.)abdominal surgery Low risk of bias Suggesting
NCT00333021 ongoing fondaparinuxcontrol - NCT00333021
FONDACAST ongoing fondaparinuxnadroparin - NCT00843492
PROTECT (fundaparinux) ongoing fondaparinuxno treatment - NCT00881088
NCT00320398 ongoing fondaparinuxcontrol - NCT00320398
fraxiparin
Pezzuoli, 1989nadroparinplaceboSuggesting
Leyvraz, 1991nadroparinUnfractionated heparinhip surgeryNegative
Roth, 1995nadroparincontrolNegative
LMWH
Harenberg, 1990LMWHUFHmedical patientsNegative
Harenberg, 1996LMWHUFHmedical patientsNegative
nadroparin
Marassi [41]nadroparinno treatmentNegative
Balas [40]nadroparinplaceboNegative
Kakkar and Murray, 1985nadroparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgerySuggesting
EFS, 1988nadroparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgerySuggesting
Dahan, 1989nadroparinunfractionated heparinthoracic surgeryNegative
Barbui, 1990nadroparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgery -
Kujath, 1993nadroparincontrol Risk of bias Suggesting
Eurin, 1994nadroparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Sourmelis, 1995nadroparinplacebohip surgerySuggesting
Nurmohamed, 1996nadroparinplaceboNegative
Bergmann, 1996nadroparinplacebomedical patientsNegative
Yoo, 1997nadroparinno treatmenthip surgeryNegative
NPHDO, 1998out of hospital Nadroparinstandard prophylaxisNegative
Fraisse, 2000Nadroparinplacebomedical patientsNegative
Mahe, 2005Nadroparinplacebomedical patientsNegative
KANT (7 days), 2008nadroparincontrol Risk of bias Suggesting
KANT (14 days), 2008nadroparin 14dcontrol Risk of bias Suggesting
PROTECT (nadroparin) ongoing nadroparinno treatment - NCT00881088
phenindione
Eskeland, 1966Phenindioneno treatment -
Hamilton, 1970Phenindioneno treatment -
reviparin
Kakkar, 1993reviparinunfractionated heparingeneral surgery -
Wirth, 2001reviparincontrol Low risk of bias Negative
Lassen, 2002reviparinplacebo Low risk of bias Suggesting
rivaroxaban
ODIXa-KNEE, 2005rivaroxabanenoxaparin (US regimen)knee surgery Exploratory Negative
ODIXa-HIP 10mg, 2006rivaroxabanenoxaparin (short duration)hip surgery Exploratory Suggesting
RECORD 1, 2008rivaroxabanenoxaparinhip surgery Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00329628
RECORD 3, 2008rivaroxabanenoxaparin (europe regimen)knee surgery Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00361894
RECORD 2, 2008rivaroxaban (long duration)enoxaparin (short duration)hip surgery Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00332020
RECORD 4, 2009rivaroxabanenoxaparin (US regimen)knee surgery Low risk of bias SuggestingNCT00362232
MARINER, 2018rivaroxabanplacebomedical patientsSuggesting NCT02111564
suloctidil
Turpie, 1985Suloctidilplacebo Low risk of bias -
ticlopidine
Walker, 1974ticlopidineplacebo Exploratory -
Lasierra, 1982ticlopidineplacebo Exploratory -
McKenna-II, 1983Ticlopidineplacebo Exploratory Negative
McKenna-II , 1983ticlopidineplaceboNegative
Lyon-IITiclopidineplacebo Exploratory Negative
GardeckiTiclopidineplacebo Exploratory Negative
tinzaparin
Bergqvist [42]tinzaparinplaceboNegative
Lassen, 1991tinzaparinplacebohip surgerySuggesting
Leizorovicz, 1991tinzaparinunfractionated heparinabdominal surgery -
Jorgensen, 2002tinzaparincontrol Risk of bias Negative
UFH
CadeUFHcontrolmedical patients -
Kakkar (IMT)UFHno treatment -
GruberUFHno treatment -
TorngrenUFHplacebo -
Handley (low dose), 1972UFHcontrol Risk of bias Negative
Handley, 1972UFHcontrol Risk of bias Negative
Gordon-Smith, 1972UFHno treatment -
Nicolaides, 1972UFHno treatment -
Kakkar, 1972UFHplacebo -
Gallus, 1973UFHcontrol Risk of bias Negative
Emerson, 1973UFHcontrol Risk of bias Suggesting
Warlow, 1973UFHcontrol Low risk of bias Suggesting
Gallus , 1973UFHno treatmentNegative
Gallus , 1973UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Gallus, 1973UFHno treatment -
Morris, 1974UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Dechavanne, 1974UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Multiunit, 1974UFHno treatment -
Abernethy, 1974UFHno treatment -
Sagar, 1974UFHno treatment -
Kettunen, 1974UFHno treatment -
Hampson, 1974UFHplaceboNegative
VTCSG, 1975UFHno treatmentNegative
Dechavanne, 1975UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Sebeseri, 1975UFHno treatment -
Abraham-Inpijn , 1975UFHplaceboNegative
Lahnborg, 1975UFHplacebo -
Covey, 1975UFHplacebo -
Strand, 1975UFHplacebo -
Roberts, 1975UFHplacebo -
Ribaudo, 1975UFHplacebo -
Mannucci , 1976UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Galasko , 1976UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Gallus, 1976UFHno treatment -
Kraytman, 1976UFHno treatment -
Lahnborg, 1976UFHplacebo -
Loew, 1977UFHaspirin -
Morris , 1977UFHno treatmentNegative
Kraytman, 1977UFHno treatment -
van Geloven, 1977UFHoral anticoagulant -
Xabregas , 1977UFHplaceboNegative
Wu, 1977UFHplacebo -
Lawrence, 1977UFHplacebo -
Kraytman, 1977UFHplacebo -
Kutnowski, 1977UFHplacebo -
Coe, 1978UFHno treatment -
Allen, 1978UFHno treatment -
Cerrato, 1978UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Williams , 1978UFHplaceboNegative
Moskovitz, 1978UFHplaceboSuggesting
Moskovitz, 1978UFHplaceboNegative
Kiil, 1978UFHplacebo -
Torngren, 1978UFHplacebo -
Taberner, 1978UFHplacebo -
Torngren, 1978UFHplacebo -
Bergqvist , 1979UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Bergqvist, 1979UFHno treatmentSuggesting
Plante, 1979UFHno treatment -
Abraham-Inpijn, 1979UFHno treatment -
Groote Schuur, 1979UFHno treatment -
Ziemski, 1979UFHno treatment -
Hedlund, 1979UFHplacebo -
Vinazzer, 1980UFHaspirin -
Bergqvist, 1980UFHno treatment -
Lahnborg, 1980UFHplaceboSuggesting
Belch, 1980UFHplacebo -
Kruse-Blinkenberg, 1980UFHplacebo -
Vandendris, 1980UFHplacebo -
Pitt, 1980UFHplacebo Risk of bias Negative
Blech, 1981UFHcontrolmedical patientsSuggesting
Spebar, 1981UFHno treatment -
Lowe , 1981UFHplaceboSuggesting
Svend-Hansen, 1981UFHplaceboSuggesting
Welin-Berger, 1982UFHno treatmentNegative
Koppenhagen, 1982UFHno treatment -
Marchetti, 1982UFHplacebo -
Clarke-Pearson, 1983UFHno treatment -
Marchelli, 1983UFHno treatment -
Bejjani, 1983UFHplacebo -
Muiticentre 53,S4, 1984UFHDHE -
Muiticentre, 1984UFHDHE -
Caloghera, 1984UFHno treatment -
Muiticentre, 1984UFHplacebo -
Jourdan, 1984UFHplacebo -
Zawilska, 1989UFHcontrol Risk of bias Suggesting
Gardlund, 1996UFHcontrolmedical patientsSuggesting
Manganelli, 1998out of hospital UFHstandard prophylaxisNegative
warfarin
Myrhe, 1969WarfarinDextran -
Myrhe, 1969Warfarinplacebo -
Pinto, 1970Warfarinno treatment -
Harris, 1972WarfarinDextran -
Hume, 1973Warfarinno treatment -
Hume, 1973WarfarinSudoxicam -
Hume, 1973Warfarinunfractionated heparin -
Morris, 1976Warfarinno treatment -
Barber, 1977WarfarinDextran -
Barber, 1977Warfarinunfractionated heparin -
Francis, 1983WarfarinDextran -
Paiement, 1987WarfarinIntermittent pneumatic compression -
Powers, 1989WarfarinAspirin -
Powers, 1989Warfarinno treatment -
Gerhart, 1991WarfarinDanaparoid -
Bailey, 1991WarfarinIntermittent pneumatic compression -
Kaempffe, 1991WarfarinIntermittent pneumatic compression -
Francis, 1992WarfarinIntermittent pneumatic compression -
Hull, 1993WarfarinLogiparinSuggesting
RD Heparin, 1994WarfarinArdeparinSuggesting
Leclerc, 1996WarfarinEnoxaparinSuggesting
Heit, 1997WarfarinArdeparinSuggesting
Lotke, 1997WarfarinAspirin -
Francis, 1997WarfarinDalteparinSuggesting
van Comp, 1998WarfarinDanaparoid -
Colwell, 1999WarfarinEnoxaparinSuggesting
Hull, 2000WarfarinDalteparinSuggesting
Fitzgerald, 2001WarfarinEnoxaparinSuggesting
ximelagatran
Phase II (Heit), 2001ximelagatranEnoxaparinNegative
METHRO I, 2002ximelagatranDalteparinNegative
METHRO II, 2002ximelagatranDalteparinSuggesting
METHRO III, 2002ximelagatranEnoxaparinNegative
Platinum (Colwell), 2003ximelagatranEnoxaparinNegative
EXPRESS, 2003ximelagatranEnoxaparinSuggesting

graduated compression stockings

UFH
Torngren, 1980GCS + UFHUFHSuggesting
Wille-Jorgensen, 1985GCS + UFHUFHSuggesting
*Rasmussen (adj), 1988GCS + UFHUFHNegative
Wille-Jorgensen, 1991GCS + UFHUFHSuggesting

mechanical devices for thromboprophylaxis

aspirin
Hull (+asp), 1979IPC + aspirinaspirinNegative
Hull 2 (+asp), 1979IPC + aspirinaspirin -
Lieberman (A), 1994IPC + aspirinaspirinNegative
Gelfer, 2006CECT + aspirinLMWH -
UFH
Siragusa (H), 1994IPC + UFHUFHNegative
Ramos, 1996IPC + UFHUFHSuggesting
Killewich, 1997IPC + UFHcontrolNegative